A geriatrician must be many things: doctor, comforter, detective, humble warrior, magician.
By Beth Macy
published Sunday, May 25, 2008
He’s a former Green Beret, a tough guy with a middle-aged paunch and a staccato-speed New York accent. If you happen to be the nurse or medical student walking next to him — and trying to take notes — he’s likely to snap his fingers at you and half-jokingly scold:
“You’re on Camardi speed now! Keep up!”
A woman hugs Dr. Michael Camardi after he told her that he’s not giving up on her father, who suffered a stroke.
But inside Ruth Kelley’s room at Springtree, a nursing home in Northeast Roanoke, the fast-talking tough guy turns soft, a country doctor type who seems to have all the time in the world.
When Carilion Clinic recruited Dr. Michael Camardi to work at its Center for Healthy Aging a year and a half ago, he was 58 years old and planning to scale back his schedule with an eye toward retirement.
Instead, he found himself embattled — at the office, at the hospital, at the nursing home, even on the phone.
But unlike his medic days in Vietnam, he couldn’t order reinforcements.
There simply wasn’t anyone to call.
Pick your report. Last month, the National Academy of Sciences issued the latest crisis call: There aren’t enough doctors trained in geriatrics, not enough med-school students entering the field and, even if the crop of students improved, there wouldn’t be enough doctors to teach them.
Ask Camardi to define his role, and he doesn’t say “doctor” or “professor” or even “medical director” — all of which, incidentally, he is.
Camardi sums up his mission to care for the elderly in a single word: warrior.
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Newsvine
Facebook
Google
Technorati
Dr. Camardi on Aging
I love the statement that Dr. Camardi made at the end of this article. He said, As much care and consideration should go into treating a 93-year-old nursing home patient with dementia as a healthy 25-year-old who shows up in the E.R. I took care of my 92 yr. old mother and had people say you need to be ready to give her up. Of course, I didn't want to give her up but the problem was I expected her to have the best medical care possible as if she was a young person as long as she was living. One doctor told me when she was 86 that she was dying and I said I know someday but right now let's find out what is going on that is causing her to lose weight and not get her strength back. I also got some other doctors involved in her case and it turned out to be her medication was upsetting her stomach so they started her on Zantac and she immediately started eating and gaining her strength and went on to live a very good life until 92 yrs. old. It makes me shriver when I hear doctor after doctor say "oh, you are just getting old and that's part of it" instead of finding out what is really going on. I just lost my husband and feel that more could have been done to made his life better if only the doctors would have taken the time to run a few tests or xrays to see what had happened to his back in the very beginning. I'm not saying we don't have very good medical care in the United States but that more could be done for the elderly. I have a soft spot in my heart when it comes to these people. I also would like to do what I can to help some of these people in same way.
Thank you for your
Thank you for your response--and I just have to tell you that it comes down to the individual.What I mean by that is when I talk with a family or a patient about matters such as these,I present my moral basis and then I turn the tables and ask them about their value-based descion process.YES--it does come down to a very fundamnetal clearing of the ethical and moral mine-field we all walk upon when dealing with our mutual sense of what is right and what is wrong.In the almost 30 years in which I have done this work,I am always surprised when I see the reaction of people when I bring them to this rather seismic moment.Only then can we have a fair and honest discussion. That is why I motivate my students to think about these issues now--as we all should.By exploring those diffilcult emotions when we are not confronted by eternity,it helps us make better judgements later on.
Exactly
Great perspective...but woe to those who are trying to negotiate this recession and the general attitude of doctors toward what might ail older people. As you observe, "it's just age" is all too common an alternative to treating the problem.
Thanks for your
Thanks for your response--and yes,sometimes it is just the process of time--but how does the patient feel about that?Do we force it upon them and walk away or do we give a plan of some form of action to help them help themsleves--exercise,diet and proper sleep habits. I can't tell you how these simple things do help to some degree if we work on them and if nothing else, when dealing with them,it opens doors to other issues such as poly-pharmacy.