Yesterday, I received an e-mail from blog reader Whitney, who has been craving a favorite treat from her childhood.
Here’s what Whitney had to say:
Today I attended a wake and there on the dessert table were Peanut Butter Fingers…the exact same ones that the Salem schools used to serve every Friday on pizza day. Not only were they delicious but they took me way back (it’s been many years since high school). I would love to have that recipe to make for my kids but I’m not having much luck searching online and the container they were in didn’t have a name on it. Do you happen to have the recipe or could you point me in the right direction to possibly find it…and maybe the pizza recipe too?
Well, I wrote Whitney back and asked her for a little more information about the dessert and her time in Salem schools. She said the fingers “looked like they were fixed in a sheet pan…they were flat and cut into small squares.” The bottom of these dessert bars were peanut butter, chewy and made with oatmeal. The top was chocolatey, like icing.
“I didn’t enjoy school lunches much but I LOVED these. I was in Salem schools from 1980 to 1993 (which doesn’t seem real to me somehow),” Whitney said.
I found a similar recipe online, which I will attach below. But it calls for chocolate chips on top so it may not be the same. While I call Salem schools in an effort to track down this recipe, I thought I’d check with all of my wonderful readers to see if any of you remember a treat like these. Better yet, maybe one of you has the recipe! If you do, please be sure to let us know!
Read more »