April 3, 2008Some thoughts on the bottom threeHere is the column I wrote for Friday's paper. It sums up a few thoughts about this week's show, specifically questions about the order in which participants are kicked off. I was really surprised when Brooke turned up in the bottom three. What about y'all? The Clark Brothers a little over the top
I was really excited to see the Clark Brothers perform on the show last night. We've written a lot about them recently because they are from this neck of the woods (Franklin County). I didn't watch "The Next Great American Band," but I heard only rave reviews about the Clarks. I wasn't bowled over, to say the least, by their performance of "This Little Light of Mine." In fact, I felt like I'd been hit over the head with a lamp. It was a weird performance. Lead singer Ashley seemed nervous and you could barely hear his vocals, which were drowned out by his brothers' instruments. They are definitely a talented crew; I just think they were trying too hard last night. Almost like killing an ant with a bulldozer. April 2, 2008Adios, RamieleIt's time for Ramiele to pack up and hit the road. Tonight was the first night she was in the bottom three, but it shouldn't have been. Don't get me wrong, I think Ramiele has a lot of potential; her voice is great. In fact, I think she gave her best performance tonight of all nights b/c she finally had some emotion behind her voice. Still, move along.... Brooke White in the bottom three?? More on that later. David Cook rushed to the hospital
According to news reports, David Cook was taken to the hospital Tuesday night following the show because of heart palpitations. According to TMZ.com, "show medics said Cook's blood pressure was 'far too high' and urged the aspiring 'Idol' to seek treatment, but he did not want to leave until the show concluded." Following a dose of meds to bring down his blood pressure, he was released and is said to be doing fine. I guess all this excitement is really getting to him. It's a wrap on DollyBrooke set the stage with Dolly's "Joleen," which was a good song choice for her. It was a little rushed, but the acoustic ensemble was a clever way to switch gears after being called out by Paula and Simon ... go with the band, don't go with the band ... the past two weeks. Brooke is pretty consistent and was in her element singing a Dolly song. It's hard to stack these kids up against the icons, though. Simon felt she lacked emotion, which is a total crock. The day Brooke White lacks any emotion is the day we should all be afraid. David Cook brought his usual greatness with "Little Sparrow," but honestly, I'm getting a little bored. He's awesome, don't get me wrong. And I still dig him a lot, but it would be nice to see something a little different. He's talented, sure, and I have to appreciate the fact that he makes these songs his own, never going to that place other contestants go when they mimic other singers. But it's all starting to sound the same. April 1, 2008My thoughts on the bottom threeMy prediction for the bottom 3 after tonight's performance of Dolly Parton songs: Kristy Lee Cook sang one of my all-time favorite Dolly songs. "Coat of Many Colors" always makes me cry, but Kristy Lee's version only made me giggle. Sorry, KLC. Bottom three. Ramiele Malubay sang "Do I Ever Cross Your Mind." It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't something we'll remember, either. Sorry, Ramiele, it's time for you to visit the bottom 3 stools once and for all. Jason Castro, who I love, by the way. But his performance just pales in comparison to the actual stars of the show. But, I'll pitch a tent next to your stage at FloydFest, Jason. I swear! My favorites tonight? Syesha. Yep. I loved it. And Michael Johns. He's sneaking up on David Cook. He nailed it tonight. More analysis coming. Keep an eye out. Add your two cents. Or three. Or four. How will they do Dolly?
I'm trying to imagine how Tuesday night's show will go down with the participants singing Dolly Parton songs. I wonder who will sing "Islands in the Stream"? Or "9 to 5." Who will shake things up? Will Kristy Lee come out on top this week because this is more her genre? How will Michael Johns or David Cook pull off a Dolly song? Who will sing "Coat of Many Colors"? I have a lot of questions. I can't wait to see how it all pans out. For the record, I'm a big fan of Dolly Parton. Note: The Clark Brothers will perform Wednesday night on "Idol." The Clark bros. are from Franklin County. Here's a story we did on them when they won "The Next Great American Band." |
.....Advertisement.....
|
...Advertisement...
...Advertisement...
