...Advertisement...

...Advertisement...

This season could turn even Brooke White into a cynic

Here's my latest column on "Idol" happenings. Enjoy!

I'm still sad about Carly's departure.

Carly gone? My confidence in America is way low

I've gotten too invested apparently. But I have not much to say right now. Even the folks who don't like Carly Smithson know that she's way more talented than Jason Castro. And Brooke White. And Syesha. The wind has left my sail. I'm glad I'm going to Europe for 2 weeks. More on that later. I'm sad. There went the talent.

OK, really? Carly in the bottom 2???

Jason Castro beat Carly? Really, America? Are you serious? This show is ridiculous.

Where they stand

Aside from Brooke White's major misstep (which broke my heart), I think tonight's performances were truly representative of each competitor's skill level.

Brooke: Not always consistent, but can bring you to tears when she nails it
David Archuleta: Talented voice, but never steps out of his comfort zone
David Cook: Solid every time and has incredible versatility and range
Carly Smithson: Has a very big voice, but picking the right songs is crucial
Jason Castro: A cutie and fun to listen to, but overall too weak vocally to continue
Syesha Mercado: Has a wonderful voice, but it's imperative she sings songs that mean something to her. Otherwise she's forgettable.

The Broadway blow-by-blow

No one sang "Don't Cry for Me, Argentina." I was sad. It's one of those songs I always sing, but only know like 5 words (like don't.cry.for.me.argentina).

Anyway, on to the summary.

Syesha Mercado did a great job on "One Rock and Roll Too Many." I thought parts of it were a bit forced; she was trying to split her attention between the lyrics and the animation, but she pulled it off in the end. I think her performance was solid enough to keep her in the game.

Continue reading "The Broadway blow-by-blow" »

Andrew Lloyd Webber bringing Broadway to 'Idol' stage

Tonight's "Idol" mentor is Andrew Lloyd Webber, the king of music theater. I'm actually looking forward to this one because I love Broadway. I think the standouts tonight will be David Archuleta (yes, I said it!) and Brooke White. I can totally see David A. singing something from "Cats." Dull.

I did some reading, and according to Webber in an interview with the Los Angeles Times, "The girl who I was really quite impressed with was Brooke. She was really -- I got something out of her. I mean, whether or not, you know, that is there at the end, I really couldn't tell you." Yay, Brooke White!

Should be an interesting night. I wonder how David Cook will fare? Maybe he'll do something funky with "The Music of the Night" from "The Phantom of the Opera."

"Don't Cry for Me, Argentina" would make a great final song for the person who gets voted off. More like "Don't Cry for Me, American Idol."

Search


Recent comments

  • Yeppers. Your country is falling apart and turning into a police state while you're being ...more - doug Ward
  • LOL!! Great column and great sense of humor! I'm telling you, we're not all bad, ...more - LetThatBeALesson
  • Ever since my slam on Neil Diamond (sorry - I am STILL not a fan), ...more - Amy Hanek
  • I was pretty shocked too. I mean I was ready to point my finger towards ...more - Amy Hanek
  • I'll admit that I enjoyed the Graham Nash/Brooke performance, too. (Even though I'm making fun ...more - Wendy Maxey

Related links

From the Roanoke Times/roanoke.com

About this blog

That TV Blog is the Roanoke Times' blog for all things TV. A handful of folks from our staff riff on their favorite and not-so-favorite shows here. | Read more about the contributors and this blog

E-mail address for roanoke.com

RSS feed

.....Advertisement.....