Land of Opportunity

The Roanoke Times

In increasing numbers, Hispanic immigrants are putting down roots in the Roanoke Valley. They're pouring concrete, opening hair salons and filling classrooms. Some employers, meanwhile, are attributing their success to this new labor pool. In this occasional series, The Roanoke Times explores the local impact of the national debate about immigration.
Recent Roanoke Times stories on Hispanic immigration have included:
gallery-immigrantsDuring a busy Friday night dinner waiter Jesus Malaga serves an armload of food to their Anglo customers. Malaga came to America four years ago from Mexico and, like many Mexican immigrants in Roanoke, first landed a job at El Rodeo.

December 31, 2006

As Congress wrestles with what to do about the estimated 12 million illegal Hispanic immigrants, friends and relatives keep showing up on the Roanoke doorsteps of those already settled here. The Roanoke Times documents the people behind the debate in this series of occasional articles titled “Land of Opportunity.”

Though some subjects were reluctant to have their names used and photographs taken out of fear of being deported, many believed that telling their stories would put a human face on a growing population that is still largely invisible — but which openly co-exists — in our community. In most cases, the newspaper has not pinpointed where the immigrants live or where they are employed.

Beth Macy

Beth Macy has been a features writer at The Roanoke Times since 1989. Macy gravitates toward stories that feature real-life struggles of ordinary people, with profile articles that have garnered national feature-writing awards and Virginia Press Association honors. She has published freelance articles in salon.com, The Christian Science Monitor and The Chronicle of Higher Education, and taught literary journalism at Hollins University.

Josh Meltzer

Josh Meltzer has been a photographer at The Roanoke Times since 1999. Earlier this year, Meltzer was named Photographer of the Year (Under 115,000 Circulation) by the National Press Photographers Association. Meltzer previously was a staff photographer at the Duluth (Minn.) News-Tribune for four years. In addition to his still photography, Meltzer has photographed, recorded, edited and produced more than two dozen video, audio and multimedia online presentations that have received awards from the Virgininia News Photographers Association and the Society for News Design.

In 2005, Macy and Meltzer teamed up to produce "An Unlikely Refuge," a multimedia series documenting the resettlement of Somali Bantu refugees in Roanoke. Their work won several national awards, including the 2006 Digital Edge Award for multimedia storytelling and the Associated Press Managing Editors award for online convergence.

Evelio Contreras

Evelio Contreras has been a reporter at The Roanoke Times since June 2005. He began as an editorial assistant in Metro and is now the community sports writer for the New River Valley Current, Neighbors and Sports. Contreras hopes to write narrative stories with a photographer's eye for detail. Before moving to Roanoke, Contreras was a desk assistant at The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer on PBS and worked as a sports editor of The News Gram in Eagle Pass, Texas. He graduated in June 2004 with journalism and philosophy degrees at Northwestern University.

Reporters: Beth Macy, Evelio Contreras

Photographer/multimedia: Josh Meltzer

Online designer: Amanda Hicks

Online producer: Jordan Fifer

Editor: Carole Tarrant

Multimedia editor: Seth Gitner

Print designer: Terri Macklin

Photo editor: Michael Stowe

Graphics: Grant Jedlinsky, Rob Lunsford

Copy editor: Alison Weaver

July 23, 2006

A growing presence

Roanoke Hispanics are crowding classrooms, filling church pews, opening stores and shopping en masse at that most American of places: the Valley View Wal-Mart Supercenter, which recently dedicated an entire aisle to their specialty foods.

Though 2004 census figures said Hispanics numbered fewer than 2,000 in the city, informed people are saying — and there is physical evidence — that the population is much larger, at least five times more.

In Roanoke, Hispanic immigrants — some here legally, many not — have begun to reach a critical mass.

The growth in the Roanoke Valley’s Hispanic population can be seen in the number of new churches that cater almost exclusively to Hispanics. The members of this one, the Iglesia de Dios (Church of God) near Williamson Road, are mostly from Honduras.Gallery Open The growth in the Roanoke Valley’s Hispanic population can be seen in the number of new churches that cater almost exclusively to Hispanics. The members of this one, the Iglesia de Dios (Church of God) near Williamson Road, are mostly from Honduras.

From the woman packaging your bread to the man cutting your meat, the estimated 12 million people behind the issue of illegal immigration were living mostly quiet lives — until their presence became a matter of white-hot national debate this spring.

Why are they landing here, and what shape will their collective footprint take?

They could mean the difference between a growing Roanoke and a shrinking Roanoke: Since 1980, the city’s population has dropped more than 7,000 residents, with a median age that ranks as the 12th-oldest in the nation.

Alvanzo Bello (left) and Victor Gonzalez (right) march outside the Roanoke City Goverment building along Campbell Ave. on May 1 while taking part in the Day Without Immigrants March held in cities across America. Amidst a national debate and like thousands of other Hispanic workers across the county, the two took the day off from work to push for immigrants' rights.Soundslide Open Alvanzo Bello (left) and Victor Gonzalez (right) march outside the Roanoke City Goverment building along Campbell Ave. on May 1 while taking part in the Day Without Immigrants March held in cities across America. Amidst a national debate and like thousands of other Hispanic workers across the county, the two took the day off from work to push for immigrants' rights.

That picture changes dramatically when you factor in the thousands of Roanoke Hispanics who operate below the radar, uncounted by census takers. Hispanic leaders put the number somewhere between 10,000 and 12,000 and as large as 16,000 for the entire Roanoke Valley.

As church activist Lucy Tamez put it: “For every legal Latino I know, there are nine more illegal ones,” many in their 20s and younger.

If those figures are correct, it’s possible that not only is the city growing — using the conservative end of the estimate, Hispanics now make up 9.6 percent of the city’s population — but it’s also getting younger.

“In the past five years, Roanoke has become a pretty receptive settlement city for our people, and they are helping the city to grow,” said Enrique Escorza, consul general of Mexico, during an April documentation clinic at Preston Park Primary School. “They work hard for the people who hire them, which is incidentally why they are here: for dollars, not because they like the mountains of Roanoke.”

« Postscript | Crowding classrooms »

Comments

Have you noticed that the people who object the most to Spanish speaking immigrants, don't know how to spell, punctuate, or capitalize in English? !! And just because you hear someone speaking in Spanish does not mean they can't speak or understand English. If you go to a foreign country with others from America, even if you can speak the language of that country, you will probably speak to your friends and family in English. And it is not only Spanish that I hear when I am shopping or eating out, I hear many other languages being spoken by the people around me. Most of those you hear out there are legal, and if they aren't you would never know it by the way they act, walk, talk, or the music they listen to! If they could support their families in their own countries, they probably would not be here, and if they could get here legally, they wouldn't be illegal. No one wants to be an illegal! That is not a desire, it is sometimes a necessary evil so you don't have to watch your children starve to death or die because they can't get health care. You bigots out there need to grow a heart!

When we give them citizenship they can run back an forth as they please with their drugs guns just what ever they want to do come here an get there welfair checks an go back home the other 29 days the fact is there here to drain america the sad thing is were alowing them to take over there killing more of our people than the iraqs we need an alamo 2

I have spent most of my life in service to my county and do not care to see it being deteriorated from within because of our elected officials unwillingness to take a stand. I have also lived in the Roanoke Valley for about the past 14 years and would rater move elsewhere than to live in an area that quietly and knowingly allows sanctuary to illegal aliens. I would much rather see my tax dollars being spent on T walling the mexican border with only one access point per state and hiring enough INS agents to effectively go state to state deporting all illegal aliens and barring reentry into our country. Our contry also needs toughened legislation that allows for extremely stiff fines and penalties for companies that hire undocumented workers. What very few people fail to realize is that when someone gains citizenship then thier entire immediate family is then eligible for citizenship. If we give 12 million illegals citizenship the we are looking at the possibility of 100's of millions being allowed in and destroying any and all of our social programs, overwhelming public school systems and making health care completely unaffordable because of the loss of revenue from all the immigrants that receive care and cant or wont pay. Let also not forget about the drugs, and crime such from gangs such as MS13 that are comprised mostly of hispanics. I have bled and sacrificed so that my children could grow up in a better world not a worse one.

What a shame that the author sanitizes this issue?

Have you seen what illegal immigration has done to Los Angeles and most of southern California?
Are you Americans that stupid?

These illegal foreigners are taking over every neighborhood they can grab and they don't accept Americans or anyone that does not look like them!
You want this land to become Mexico?
Go ahead and let them stay and see what you will go though!

You are all CRAZY!
No to illegal immigration!
Deport all illegal aliens back to their homelands.

I think I agree with the majority. Mexican workers in Roanoke and across america are hard workers here soley to make a better life for themselves and their families. However, if they are illegal they need to be deported. Our tax dollars have enough hands out for them. We can't keep solving everyone elses problems. If they are so valuable to our work force then let their employers foot the bill to obtain a legal status
them. Yeah, right. They need to play by the rules or go home!!!!!!!

If you want to come here to the united states legal thats fine but when you do it illegal i have a problem with that. you come over here you make your pay check and send it back to your wife and daughter. so you can live high on a hog when you decide to go back to mexico. you can by a car drive illegal wihtout a drivers license,insurance, and our goverment will still issue you tages even tho you dont have a driver license's. but as long as your tickets have been payed, well issue you a set of tags no problem. great here's your set of tags go home put them on your car. get out on our roads and risk everyones life becasue if you cant read out road signs our language or your native language. THEN YOU SHOULDNT BE ALLOWED TO DRIVE... BUT NO OUR GOVERMENT MUST WONT YOU ONE THE ROAD. OH BUT YOU CAN GO TO NORTH CAROLINA THEY WILL GIVE YOU A LICENSE THEN YOU CAN MOVE TO VIRGINIA.
BUT NOW LET AN AMERICAN GET CAUGHT WIHTOUT A LICENSE AND NO INSURANCE WE GET ARRESTED AND SPEND LONGER TAHN 4 HOURS IN JAIL .. BUT ITS OK FOR AN ILLEGAL ALIEN TO DO JUST THAT WHAT DOES THAT TELL US ABOUT OUR GOOD OLE GOVERMENT.............

I think that everybody has the chance to come to the U.S if they come legally!!!But they shouldn't be allowed to come here and get welfare, foodstamps and live off of our tax payers money.We have our own kids that are going without food and medical help,also if they want to come to the U.S they HAVE TO LEARN HOW TO SPEAK ENGLISH ihate to walk into a place and all you here is #%&*^& i say controll our boarders (thats what we pay law enforcement to do)don't give them welfare and i bet half of them will stay where there at.belive me i hope our senetars are reading this because i'll be watching very closely who i'll be voting for this election!!!!

Recently having moved to Roanoke from El Paso, TX I feel the issue is the difficulty that Mexicans have when they are not people of means and try to follow the proper procedures to immigrate into our country. I watched over the seven years I was there issue after issue that one family of friends were faced with and the expense it was for them to try to bring other family members to the US as well as to become citizens themselves. They are milked of what little funds and savings they have by lawyers and procedures day after day. This family was afraid to make waves because they feared they would lose what they had already gained. Poor Mexican people do not stand a chance with the system and become very discouraged when others pass them by because of funding or connections.
Make the path fair, equal and easier to follow and most Mexican immigrants will follow it. I left some of the most honest, family loving, and hard working friends I have ever known behind when I moved back to Virginia.

To all the people that shun upon immigrants being here in the valley are just blind.

Stop crying about it, there is so much to share and there are plenty of jobs here for every one.

I actually do not see any americans working in many of the harder jobs, ie. farming, construction, roofing, landscape.
So, all the white people rather have cushy jobs. They are just here to take the jobs that lazy Americans do not want.

They are not bothering anyone. Taxes are going in many other areas that are not to many Americans liking. But Americans have a lot of time an their hands and have nothing better to do, but to complain.

Get over it.
Some where in your family tree, you were once an immigrant. You are no better than the person sitting or standing next to you, but you wish to think that you are just to make yourself feel better.

“They work hard for the people who hire them, which is incidentally why they are here: for dollars, not because they like the mountains of Roanoke.” said Enrique Escorza, consul general of Mexico, during an April documentation clinic at Preston Park Primary School.

Mr. Escorza says it best, illegal aliens are not here to be part of the rich Southwestern Virginia culture. These people do not respect our country, State, or its people.

The resources needed for the millions of American citizens in need is being stolen by 20 million illegal aliens. I resent my tax dollars supporting a crimial interprise.

illegal immigrant don,t have same benefits of
the legal has.
illegals pays taxes and they can not clain
the end of year, because they do not have
a valid social security number.

We really need to let up off these "Immigrnts"., after all how many of us can say we are true Anericans? Only the Native Indians. Before we attack these "Immigrants", we need to read our history books. The Indians were the first inhabitants of this country. The opportunistic Europeans (our forefathers), came and stole their lands among other things. I really have no time to delve into this at this moment, but the point I am trying to get across is that the majority of us "Americans" do have some form of immigrant roots. If the Indians had the power that we are wielding today, where would we all be? Certainly not in America, because they would have prevented everyone of our fore-parents from landing on these shores of America.

If the writer above who claims that 45% of all children under 5 in America are Hispanic is correct, the future is already decided. Hispanics come to America because there are jobs for them; jobs Americans can't or won't do. Construction, cleaning, farming and restaurant cooking would come to a quick halt if not for all the Hispanics. The problem is that the government makes it too difficult to come legally and thus forces the Hispanics into an illegal mode. The jobs are here and the Hispanics are here - a more common sense solution is needed.

The MAIN reason I moved to Roanoke from Harrisonburg was because Middle class families such as myself, where increasingly surrounded by Hispanic families moving in next door. There were always a house full 6 or more living in one house, not including the children. It was loud and there was NEVER a place to park, as they owned multiple cars. Now, as I drive around Roanoke as see the same trend beginning, I think it's time to move elsewhere. I'm not being judgemental I'm being realistic! If you enjoy coming home relaxing after work in your own yard, then things are about to change. Get used to Loud talking, loud music and a lot of people around. A lot of Roanoker's are being very naive about being so inviting to immigrants and extremely too accomodating.

I fought a War to prevent OUR COUNTRY/VIRGINIA
from being INVADED by Any ILLEGAL NATIONALS and
INVADERS - and Very much resent Anyone: Government
State and City officials, allowing such Disgusting
Support for ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS FROM MEXICO, LATIN
AMERICA, and ELSEWHERE.
VIrginia is for those who want to become AMERICANS
-NOT A THIRD CLASS NATION OR STATE !
Let OUR next election Speak Loud And Clear: build
border fences,heavily fine employers of Illegals,
and return ALL who do not LEGALLY BELONG HERE !

I do not think people are upset with immigrants coming over to America and setting up a better life for their families. All of us came from somewhere. I think people are upset for two reasons. The first is how the illegal immigrants may be coming into America. Some, not all, are sneaking over the borders at night, hiding inside cars, or arriving by boatloads. They should do it the legal way. Working on a visa, learning the language so there will be an easier transition for their families, and taking the citizenship test(no matter what a joke that test may be). The second reason why people are so upset is that our taxpayers money is paying to support a large number of them. 29% are using 1 major welfare program. Immigrants and their minor children account for 1 in 4 living in poverty. 1/3 lack any health insurance. 34% had not completed high school. 45% of all children under the age of 5 in America are Hispanic. So when you see these statistics it makes people angry. Immigrants deserve to come here legally and Americans deserve to express their frustration with the ones who do it illegally. I welcome anyone that comes in the legal way.

Everyone is very quick to judge these “illegal” immigrants, but how many of you actually have been in a home of these people or have taken the time to get to know them? You will find their culture has maintain strong family values and the children are far more respective than todays “American” children. Maybe we can learn something from them!! Each one of us would do whatever measures it took to insure a better life for our own children even if it meant crossing a boarder illegally.
From Matthew ch. 7: “Don’t pass judgment on others so that you won’t be judged yourself. As you judge others, so you will yourselves be judged, and whatever action you take against others will be dealt back to you.

It is NOT the immragrants that an d others object to, it's the illegal ones and the fact that in many cases they are getting the SAME benifits as those who came legally. That is NOT right !!!!

I am so fed up with going out in Roanoke and only hearing spanish,managment postions reguiring i speak spanish, and my children having to learn Spanish in order to go to school.Jobs are being given to these people because of kick backs from the goverment to the factory's ect that hire them even though we have very quilified "Americans"that can do the job.Most of these people are here illigally but they are on our welfare roles, getting houseing and food stamps which we are paying for when "Americans" mostly the elderly can get no help at all,they speak of rights, what about American's right???Do you know that in the American Embassy in Mexico everyone has to speak spanish, so when these people come to the U.S. why don't they have to speak english? I really don't care what the nation,if there in this country they should adapt to our culture not us adjusting to theirs,the people of any nation that comes here illigally should be rounded up and deported, put on a black list and never let into our country again.The Russians have large pockets in New York City, there are many more out there. We are the only country that lets anyone in illagally or not, then takes care of all their needs while letting our own people do with out. And you wonder why people are moving away from Roanoke,and the the United States.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)