Thinking back on local health stories of 2011

The change of leadership at Carilion Clinic is just one of the big stories of the year in Southwest Virginia health care. (Photo by Stephanie Klein-Davis / The Roanoke Times)
I didn’t think it would be proper to let 2011 come to a close without first reflecting on some of the important health stories in Southwest Virginia during the year.
This isn’t the final word in important health news. So, please tell me if you agree, or point out what stories I failed to include.
(And, to be clear, this is not a ranking. The order is entirely random)
First, this is not a local story, but it has local implications. Clearly the national health care overhaul has an impact on everyone, including individuals, state government and businesses. Virginia’s part in challenging the constitutionality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act is just one of many stories that played out this year.
Another related and ongoing national story has been the rising cost of health care. We see it in the comments on this blog related to the increasing premium rates people are facing. And there are stories about how businesses are trying to slow the rising costs by offering new wellness and prevention programs, and incentives to stay healthy.
Now, to five local stories I think are worth remembering:
- LewisGale Medical Center lost its fight to open a neonatal intensive care unit to meet the health needs of its tiniest patients. And then, the Salem hospital, took the battle to court.
- Dr. Ed Murphy left his post as CEO at Carilion Clinic, and Nancy Agee took over the leadership duties.
- A whooping cough outbreak in Floyd was among the reasons a Roanoke pediatric office decided it would no longer treat patients whose parents rejected vaccines and the childhood immunization scheduled recommended by public health officials.
- Carilion Roanoke Memorial Hospital no longer met the state requirements for being Southwest Virginia’s only comprehensive place for treating trauma patients. While, the flagship hospital of Carilion Clinic, never lost its top-tier trauma status, it came under scrutiny for its ability to retain and recruit needed physicians. Just this month, Carilion said it has resolved the problem.
- Advocates from Roanoke and across the state succeeded in getting the General Assembly to pass legislation requiring Virginia insurance companies to cover the diagnosis and treatment of young children with autism spectrum disorders. But, an amendment by Gov. Bob McDonnell may prolong the law taking effect.



Hey Sarah,
I saw a billboard in Giles County that says Carilion Giles Hospital has been voted by Patients as Top 25 in the Nation. I think they meant in the Top 25 percentile? And, for what, customer service or quality? It’s a very misleading billboard… what’s the story there?
Not sure about that billboard, but related to that, 76% of the patients at Carilion Giles Community Hospital awarded the hospital a 9 or 10 on patient care, the highest percentage in the State.
@Mark McAllister thank you for your question. I’m sorry I have been slow to reply. I haven’t seen the billboard, so I’m not entirely sure what you are talking about, but I will find out more. @Susan2 Thanks for your insight. Do you know who conducts the survey you are referring to?
Here is the answer I received from Carilion Clinic spokesman Eric Earnhart about that billboard:
“Regarding the billboard, it is referring to the 4-Star Award that Carilion Giles Community Hospital received for Overall Quality of Care in Emergency Department Services, based on patient surveys conducted by Professional Research Consultants, Inc (PRC). The ranking places the hospital in the top 25%, nationally.
The billboard in question should indeed read “top 25%”. We are updating the billboard and it will be changed within the next few days.”
Would Carilion be willing to share the data from the survey?