Should regulators impose limits on the Atlantic menhaden catch? Two experts made opposing cases on Sunday. Now readers are weighing in on our blog. chris westcott wonders if one expert knows what he is talking about:

this is the guy making a case for fisheries regulation and he doesnt know the differance between a pogy and a porgy?? no wonder this subject is so inflamitory.. this guy, who knows who is buying his suits and ties,is making a case for putting alot of fisherman and others out of work.. how many days offshore has he done? porgies,scup to us rhode islanders, are ass deep these days. will the feds let the fisherman make a living on them? no is the short answer.. shaking my head..glad i got out of fishing..

What do you think?  Join the conversation and participate in the poll.