.....Advertisement.....
.....Advertisement.....
Datablog

Can Virginia really be the 12th most corrupt state in the US?

When you think of corrupt spots on the U.S. map, you might naturally think of Illinois. And certainly moreso with the arrest of Gov. Rod Blagojevich on federal corruption charges this week. Or maybe you think of Florida. Plenty of shenanigans down Miami way over the years, right?

But where would you put Virginia? I've lived here my whole life, and while journalists love a good corrupt official to chew on, I don't think of my homestate as a place with a steady diet of crooked officials.

But one study by a publication called the Corporate Crime Reporter ranked Virginia 12th, at least among the 35 most populous states in the union. Louisiana was first, followed by Mississippi, Kentucky, Alabama, Ohio and finally, at #6, Illinois. Florida was 8th.

CCR took a report from the U.S. Justice Department on prosecutions on federal corruption charges and calculated a rate of the number of charges in a state from 1997 to 2006 per 100,000 residents.

Here's a look at the number of convictions in Virginia's two federal judicial districts by year from the DOJ report:

U.S. Attorney's Office 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Totals
Virginia, Eastern 9 32 17 22 22 17 8 21 23 38 209
Virginia, Western 2 2 8 7 3 13 3 16 2 13 69

That's a total of 278 convictions over 10 years, which is way more than I would have imagined. The vast majority, though, are in the Eastern District. (This comes from a set of tables at the end of the DOJ report, by the way.)

By comparison, Illinois had 524, Louisiana had 329, and Florida had 809. Florida's Southern District had the most of any judicial district with 574.  Washington D.C. had 390, but the city's too small to make the top 35 considered, plus it's the nation's capital and is rather more overrun with public officials to begin with.

We should bear in mind that the numbers reflect not only the level of corruption, but also the interest of particular U.S. Attorneys in these kinds of cases, those same prosecutors' ability to get convictions, and other factors.

And, what the numbers don't reflect is similar kinds of cases that go through state courts. Think of Roanoke City Councilman Alfred Dowe, who double-dipped on his expense reimbursements, and whose case is before state courts. And then there's former Henry County Administrator Sid Clower, who took taxpayers for over $800,000, and was prosecuted in state court, but also picked up some charges at the federal level.

On the upside, those kinds of cases are fairly rare around here. And if you're still looking for comfort, at least our governor's name is not on the lips of every blogger and late-night comedian in the country. And if that's still not enough, be glad our governor doesn't have that peculiar hairstyle. I can stomach Gov. Tim Kaine's energetic eyebrow as long he's not selling off senate seats.

2 Comments »

  1. I think it's more likely that Virginia is just one of the more likely states to actually prosecute the corruptors!

    Comment by Roanoke RnR — December 14, 2008 @ 6:34 pm

  2. Virginia is a very corrupt state!
    I got injured here in physical therapy,
    and I got no justice for it because the crooked
    law favors doctors and medical people, who lied
    about injuring me. Some people even wanted me to
    self-pay for an injury health care caused!
    So wicked.
    The state's idea of justice is to send the person who
    harmed me to Georgia. That's their idea of punishment!
    If you don't live in VA, consider yourself lucky!

    Comment by Joyce — February 2, 2009 @ 6:22 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Search

Comments

    • Matt Chittum: Amy, we never published the full results, I don’t believe. The primary use of the results was for...
    • Amy: would love to know the results of the poll, where can I find them?
    • Beth Obenshain: Dear Matt, I have spent the last 7 1/2 years working with landowners across Southwest Virginia to...
    • LarryG: putting aside land that remains in private ownership without a specific public benefit in patchwork patterns...
    • Chris in Floyd: In addition, due the high demand, the VOF has put some minimum requirements such as the proposed...