2008.11.05
Analysis: A changing Virginia
It's morning in America, and everywhere else in this hemisphere, and the morning after a historic election brings some clarity to the numbers we were looking at with bleary eyes last night.
First, to state the obvious: Virginia is changing.
It's not just that the state cast its ballots for an African-American candidate. It did that twice before -- Doug Wilder for lieutenant governor in 1985 and Wilder again for governor in 1989.
It's not just that Virginia went Democratic, though that switch is even more historic than many of the pundits have been saying. The typical formulation is to say that this is the first time Virginia has gone Democratic since 1964. That's certainly true, but misses a larger point. That 1964 election was an aberration -- the Lyndon Johnson landslide over Barry Goldwater in the wake of John F. Kennedy's death. Before that, you have to go back to 1948 and Harry Truman to find another Democratic winner, and even he was a minority winner that year. Truman took 47.9 percent of the vote in a four-way race.
Let's put that another way: Virginia has been a reliable Republican state in presidential elections since the first Eisenhower election in 1952.
And to find a Democratic presidential candidate who has won a majority of the state's votes? Well, other than that Johnson landslide in an abnormal election year, you have to go back to 1944, when Franklin D. Roosevelt won his third term with 62 percent of the vote in the Old Dominion.
The real change is more forward-looking, and foreshadows other elections to come in the state.
I have to eat a little bit of crow because some of the rural bellwether counties I had identified in my "five places to watch" didn't ring true this year. I'm thinking of Henry County, Alleghany County and some of the counties down in the coalfields, such as Buchanan and Dickenson. In previous years, they've been swing areas. This year, they all went for McCain, and it didn't matter. Obama won the state anyway.
The reason for that, of course, is Northern Virginia, which not only continues to grow, but evolve. My two ultimate belwether counties did ring true -- Loudoun and Prince William counties. Those used to be solid GOP counties. They first flipped Democratic in the 2005 governor's race, when Tim Kaine took both. Jim Webb pulled the same trick again in the 2006 Senate race. And now Obama carried them, as well. There's an old saying that when something happens three times, it's a trend. Well, are those now even swing counties? Probably so, but we can definitely see how they're trending, and it's not Republican.
Of note: Obama not only duplicated the feat there, but he improved on the previous numbers. When Kaine won Prince William County, he did it by not quite 2 percentage points. Obama had a 12 percentage point margin there. Twelve! And when you compute what that means in terms of raw votes -- 16,408 -- well, let's put it this way, that's enough to wipe out McCain's margin in a whole slate of rural counties.
Here's a question for the future: Will we see Democrats even make much of an effort in rural Virginia in the future? Obama followed the Mark Warner model: Spend a lot of time here, and at least try to cut the margins. It didn't seem to work. Yes, I know you could say that if he hadn't done it, maybe he'd have lost here by even bigger margins. But still . . . . Obama lost counties in the coalfields that had stuck with Democrats in all but the very worst of times. (You have to go back to Richard Nixon in the 1972 landslide over George McGovern to find the last time Buchanan and Dickenson voted Republican in a presidential race.)
Now, number-wise, those localities obviously don't matter as much as Northern Virginia, but it's always been a nice thing symbolically for Democrats to point to the coalfields as evidence of their diverse base. Do they even need to bother with that anymore?
A final point: The latest numbers show Obama winning about 52 percent of the vote in the state. He's also winning 52 percent of the vote nationally. So you want a bellwether? Maybe we're it, and the reason lies up along Interstate 66.
-- Dwayne Yancey, senior editor
For other analysis of the 2008 returns, click here.





