.....Advertisement.....
.....Advertisement.....
Shanna 
Flowers

Scolding by Cosby rings true 3 years on

If Bill Cosby walked up to Virginia Smith today, the Roanoke woman would affably extend her hand.

Three years ago, Smith would have given him a piece of her mind.

She was among blacks who condemned Cosby for calling out the black underclass for its troubling ranks of unwed mothers, absent fathers, disengaged parents, high school dropouts and prison convicts.

Smith, 63, was outraged. The entertainment icon was being "uppity," she thought at the time. She stopped watching him on television afterward.

"He didn't understand," Smith said last week, recalling her reaction. She was in the camp that believed Cosby's wealth and success precluded him from saying what many of us were thinking.

"Now, I've gotten older and see more and more of what he was saying. What he was saying was true," Smith said of the comedian.

As Shakespeare wrote in King Lear, "jesters do oft prove prophets."

In recent weeks, a number of incidents and developments suggest people are getting so fed up that they're willing to publicly confront the crisis Cosby saw on the horizon three years ago -- the same one he was lambasted for voicing.

If we can get outraged enough to trek by the busload to Jena, La., then the dysfunction destroying our communities from within should compel the same outrage -- and the energy to do something about this black implosion.

"Bill was sending that message three years ago," said Ingrid Barber, 37, of Clifton Forge. "Now it's reality."


>> Last week, a desperate plea from the police chief went up in Philadelphia. Coincidentally, that's Cosby's hometown.

Beleaguered by a spiraling homicide rate, the chief put out an SOS for 10,000 black men to volunteer on neighborhood patrols to try to reduce violence that has claimed nearly 300 lives this year. Most of the victims have been young black men.

>> Last month, during a meeting with the National Association of Black Journalists, Hillary Clinton broached the plight of black men in this country.

Sure, she was shilling for votes before a captive audience. But how often have you heard a presidential candidate even bring up the issue?

>> In the pop culture arena, during the same convention at which Hillary spoke, NABJ gave Black Entertainment Television its "Thumbs Down" award, joining criticism about the network's portrayal of young blacks as thugs and loose women.

Shortly before the dubious award was announced, I met a young black scholar and dental student from North Carolina, Corey Caldwell, who has started a Web site called betdoesnotrepresentme.org.

>> In Roanoke, Patrick Henry High School educators Fletcher Nichols and Jerel Rhodes were recognized last week for mentoring 10 young black men over the past three years. This fall, all of the students entered college.

These calls to action are what Cosby implored us three years ago to do.

"I totally agreed with what he said," Taisha Claytor-Staples, a middle school counselor in Lynchburg, said last week. "People were upset because the truth hurts. A lot of time, cages have to be rattled."

Boy, did Cosby rattle cages. He made his now-famous remarks during a celebration of the 50th anniversary of Brown v. Board of Education, the landmark ruling that integrated the nation's schools.

He chastised black underachievers for a "50 percent drop-out rate ... and people in jail, and women having children by five, six different men."

America's Favorite Dad cast a harsh spotlight on parents.

"I'm talking about these people who cry when their son is standing there in an orange suit. Where were you when he was 2? Where were you when he was 12? Where were you when he was 18, and how come you don't know he had a pistol? And where is the father... ?

"These people are not parenting. They're buying things for the kid -- $500 sneakers -- for what? They won't buy or spend $250 on Hooked on Phonics."

I recall my own feelings at the time. Cosby was right, but I cringed at his candor. It would only serve to invigorate those who would use his comments to fuel their own divisive rhetoric.

That happened, of course. But who cares? We see the necessity of turning the mirror on ourselves. I'm not diminishing the outside factors that conspire against us. But I'm saying we need to address the issues that we can control.

Black columnists are writing against black-on-black violence. In this space, you've read about the necessity of black fathers' taking their rightful place in restoring the family structure, which would be a balm to reduce many of our problems.

Both nationally and locally, people are fed up and speaking out. The primary worry right now seems to be young black men.

So I drove around Roanoke late last week and happened upon some to get their feelings about being the target and focus of so much discussion.

Michael Davis was at his job at a car wash off of Orange Avenue. He understood why adults are worried about young black men. But he cautioned us not to paint everyone with a broad brush.

"A lot of young black men do a lot of stupid things. I'm just not one of them," said the Patrick Henry senior.

Davis wore a close hair cut, red T-shirt and oversized jeans. He said he carries a 2.8 grade-point average and wants to be a lawyer. But, he said people judge him by how he dresses.

"It makes me upset. Just because I wear baggy pants don't mean I'm a thug.

"I'm staying out of trouble," Davis said, adding that his mother "keeps me in the books. I'm not that unusual. It's a lot of people like me."

At 16, car wash manager Jerome Green was serving two years in juvenile detention on a drug distribution charge.

He got out, graduated from William Fleming High School and took machine and tool courses at a trade school.

The car wash is his day job. He's also trying to make a go as a rapper.

He hopes to go back to trade school, but never back to the life that robbed him of two years of freedom.

Older people, he said, worked hard and endured struggles so young people could have opportunities they didn't.

Three years ago, Cosby caused a furor because he was a prominent person airing our dirty laundry.

It seems a few people are trying to clean it up.

6 Comments »

  1. I am struggling to find the point of your story Ms. Flowers? Is it that Bill Cosby was right three years ago? Or, people dislike having their flaws pointed out? Maybe its that Ms. Smith finally figured out at age 63 that "unwed mothers, absent fathers, disengaged parents, high school dropouts and prison convicts" are problems in our society? Or, finally that two young people you found in Roanoke are working hard to accomplish goals? Some folks will never be able to solve problems on their own. Many more will never be able to look inward and even see their own faults. After the Roanoke City Schools report card in the paper last week, I can not believe that anyone would admit to being appalled by what Cosby said three years ago. Enough talk about the problem, lets talk about solutions. The point of your story should point toward a solution for this problem. I think that only individuals can change, it takes one person at a time, one family at a time. The change takes generations. It starts with one parent or maybe both graduating from high school and taking college classes, maybe even graduating from college. After having children, instilling in them that college is the next step after high school. Then the next generation wanting more than what their parents had, possibly accomplishing a graduate degree. This produces careers and with it the ability to afford nice things, such as a house you own and reliable transportation. Maybe not an expensive foreign car, but a car that you can afford and still save money for the future. A future in which you will give your children more than your parents gave you in terms of education and activities. Hopefully other families follow suit. No matter what race or nationality, this method works. Cosby was right, it takes strong parenting by either one or two parents and instilling ambition and a dedication to education. The ability to decide the right course of action is instilled in you by your family. Some families have to start breaking the cycle of governement assistance, others have to keep the college cycle going. One issue is clear, families have to stick together and help each other out. The main focus should be the children!

    Comment by Concerned in Roanoke — September 24, 2007 @ 11:12 am

  2. Concerned:

    The point of the column is that Bill Cosby was right three years ago and that people are so fed up that they are willing to publicly acknowledge the problems and try to do something about them.

    That's why I listed the various examples of what people are doing or saying to reverse the dysfunction.

    s

    Comment by Shanna — September 24, 2007 @ 7:59 pm

  3. Hi, Shanna - Another excellent column on Sunday. A good broad gathering of examples, opinions, and viewpoints. including acknowledgement of your own very interesting reaction to Cosby's remarks, well and judiciously put together. The Shakespeare quotation was a nice touch, perfectly apt, and the tag (the final pair of sentences) was ideal.

    Reaction to the Cosby speech was remarkably strong and widespread at the time, in the black community and beyond, and some of it was very unappreciative of the essence and truthfulness of his actual message, versus his audacity in saying such things aloud to the world or his “right” to speak about the black underclass from his position of wealth and success. Really, now. The man not only achieved major stardom as an actor and comedian, he also EARNED his doctoral degree in education from a major university (U. Mass.). How many other actors or comedians also are/were serious scholars? And how many would be so courageous as to risk the kind of (predictable) criticism that his remarks brought forth? Did not his thoughtful and heartfelt message deserve more respectful consideration?

    The recent turnaround from the initial rejection of Dr. Cosby’s comments, as you found in your explorations among (black) SW Virginians and others, is a very encouraging development. Your capturing of it in Sunday’s column is, for me, yet another example of the fine and valuable perspective you provide your readers, going beyond “hot news” headlines in the way that a thoughtful columnist uniquely can do.

    Keep up the good work.

    Regards, Tom

    (Thomas L. Coffman, Salem)
    (White Male, Social Psychologist)

    Comment by Thomas L. Coffman — September 25, 2007 @ 9:15 pm

  4. I was in DC two weeks ago at the White House Initiatiative on HBCU's. Look it it up if you don't know what the acronym is.

    Bill Cosby was the evening dinner keynote speaker. He was terrific and gave his message again with emphasis to an often squirming room full of HBCU presidents and grand poobahs--a group of posturing people, if you ever saw one. Decked out in their finery, Bill as much told these grand folk that through their administration of so-called academic freedoms, they perpetuate amongst too many--not all of their students and faculty--the messages and images and tragedies of no respect for themselves, others or institutions.

    Right on Bill. The message to our young, white, black, brown or yellow, is absolutely the correct one.

    Comment by roudyred — September 29, 2007 @ 11:21 am

  5. Red:

    I don't have to look it up...I graduated from one.

    Furthermore, I suspect the message that Bill Cosby delievered to presidents of HBCUs was equally applicable to presidents of majority colleges and universities.

    s

    Comment by Shanna — September 30, 2007 @ 10:08 am

  6. If you weren't there, then you have no context for your comment. Mr. Cosby was speaking to HBCU's. He specifically said that that he didn't care what everyone else was doing. Do you think that because others do something or condone poor behavior or lack of initiative or failure to exhibit self respect that it's?
    You should interview Mr. Cosby. He would fry your what-sis, if you responded to him as you did to me.

    roudyred

    Comment by roudyred — October 6, 2007 @ 11:22 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Search

About this blog

Shanna Flowers

In her signature plainspoken style, Michigan native Shanna Flowers peels away the layers and gets to the heart of the issues. No pretense. Just straightforward perspective. Shanna writes about local people whose circumstances reflect decisions made as near as City Hall or as far away as the halls of Congress. Other times, she weighs in on a topic because it is incredibly ridiculous. Or heartening. Or fascinating. Read Shanna's column three days a week, Sundays, Tuesdays and Thursdays, at roanoke.com

RSS feed

Comments

    • ms. Goldenwillow: Shanna, Thank you for this up-close glimpse, especially the feelings of Brenda Keeling — then...
    • mike: Static, my good friend: Finding a numb-nuts of Hutton’s ilk would be like looking for a pearl in a cow...
    • Static Lines: Robert Hutton None of the regular posters have used the b- word, I guess it was a regular staple at...
    • Robert Hutton: Yes I did. As well as some background info, seems she drinks from the same preverbial...
    • Ed S.: You know, several regulars go together here for “coffee” over Shanna’s thrice-weekly column....