.....Advertisement.....
.....Advertisement.....
That TV Blog

Matt G. says goodbye

Mr. Judges' Save couldn't secure a longer stay on "Idol."

Matt Giraud was sent home in Wednesday's results show. Before belting out his last tune on the stage, Matt talked about how he felt like a cat with nine lives on the show after the judges saved him from elimination a few shows back. He was one cool cat, that's for sure.

True, I wasn't crazy about his performance of "My Funny Valentine" during this week's Rat Pack music theme. I thought all the performances were stellar but found his to be the weakest of the bunch. Still, Matt from Michigan was fun to watch this season, especially when he played the piano and jazzed things up on the show. Overall, I like his style and hope he finds a way to keep performing in the future.

But the true shocker of Wednesday's show was the bottom three. Along with Matt, there was Kris Allen and Adam Lambert. Oh yes, you read that right, Adam was in the bottom three. I was stunned. While I am not an avid Adam fan, I was surprised that he was among the lowest vote-getters. I mean, the judges are always jonesing for Adam to take the stage. In their eyes, he can do no wrong. Plus, he seems to have a strong fan base. The other shocker of the night was that Adam was in the bottom two, once Kris was sent to the safe seats.

I've been saying for awhile that Adam will likely be one of the two finalists remaining but, after Wednesday, I am not quite sure. Perhaps his performance of "Feeling Good" was too flashy and over the top for many voters. Anyhow, the "Idol" game just got a lot more interesting after this development.

I will say this for all the finalists -- they were a hundred times better during their performances than this week's mentor Jamie Foxx was during his. What kind of musical mess was that? All that electronic enhancement to his voice during his song "Blame It" did nothing to improve the song. In fact, it made it worse.

Luckily, Natalie Cole and Taylor Hicks were on hand to offer up some terrific work. Natalie performed "Something's Gotta Give" and the woman has such class and talent. I loved her song. Also, former "Idol" winner Taylor took a rockabilly turn with his song "Seven Mile Breakdown." I enjoyed the energy that Taylor brought to the stage.

So, now we're down to the final four. I can't wait to see who will step up and step into "Idol" stardom.

Matt Giraud. Photo courtesy of FOX

Matt Giraud. Photo courtesy of FOX

Rat Pack tunes make for swingin' show

Ol' Blue Eyes would have been impressed with Tuesday's "Idol."

At least, I hope the late great Frank Sinatra would have been pleased because I really believe the five finalists paid wonderful tribute to songs from the Rat Pack era. Actually, this theme has been my absolute favorite so far. I really felt like everyone stepped up and showed why they should be the next "Idol."

I do have one tiny complaint. While I thought actor/singer Jamie Foxx offered some good advice as a mentor, I would have preferred to see Michael Buble (love him!) as a mentor instead because he really is kind of a modern-day Sinatra. OK, tiny complaint over.

Now, let's focus on our lone gal and four gents.

Kris Allen -- I noticed a sign held by an audience member on Tuesday that said, "Krazy for Kris." Very "kute." But enough about that, let's talk about his mad singing skills. He chose "The Way You Look Tonight" and it was terrific. He changed the arrangement a bit and upped the tempo at the end. All in all, it was another awesome moment for him. The judges also raved about the performance, except for Simon who thought it was good but not incredible.

Allison Iraheta -- The only lady left in the competition proved that she won't be overlooked in the boys' club. She performed "Someone to Watch Over Me" and it was a beautiful ballad. It is my favorite performance from the teen so far. She showed nice restraint at times but then belted out some big notes that gave the performance a boost. Bravo, little one, bravo.

Matt Giraud -- Matt chose "My Funny Valentine" and it was nice but not out of sight for me. I thought he had some pitch problems and weird phrasing in places. I agree with Randy when he said the song didn't quite "come together" very well.

Danny Gokey -- Danny definitely has a swagger going. He gave a bluesy performance of "Come Rain or Come Shine" and it was strong. He had some great vocals, and I think the performance was enough to keep Danny advancing in the competition. I do have a minor issue with Danny. Sometimes he seems a little bit arrogant when the judges give him their critiques. It's almost as if he expects them to be thrilled with his work. Danny is definitely talented but not everything he has done this season has been golden. So, show a little humbleness at times, Gokey. You haven't won this competition yet.

Adam Lambert -- Adam should be "Feeling Good," especially after the judges praised his performance of the song. He gave it a rock edge and, again, took an older song and made it original. It was over-the-top in moments but I have come to expect that from Adam. I will say this for Adam, he always seems to be genuinely touched when he gets a compliment from the judges. That impresses me. By now, the guy knows he can sing well and that he is close to the finish line of the show, but he always appears kind of surprised when the judges and the audience show him all kinds of love after a song.

OK, so who will say adios this week? I think it should be Matt. I like him, but if he advances over Allison I will be outraged. She is talented, unique and sassy and should stay in the show.

All righty, it's time to wrap up this Rat Pack entry. I already have a few of the songs still kicking around in my head. Thanks for that "Idol" and thanks for honoring Ol' Blue Eyes and his bunch.

Matt Giraud. Photo courtesy of FOX

Matt Giraud. Photo courtesy of FOX

Anoop, Lil leave on high notes

Lots of love to Lil and Anoop.

The two finalists headed home after Wednesday's results show. The double elimination was brought on after the judges used their special save last week to keep Matt Giraud in the contest.

It was fun watching Lil and Anoop this season, and I remain a fan of them both. I thought they showed some amazing talent and great attitudes throughout their run. So, I salute them.

Rounding out the bottom three, though, was teen rocker Allison Iraheta. Why America, why? The girl can sing and she's got originality and spunk. Plus, she has a crazy cool hair color. But seriously, Allison has been one of my favorite finalists because even at a young age, she steps onto that stage and comes off like a pro.

As for the rest of the results show, I appreciated the medley of disco hits to cap off this week's disco theme. Also, little David Archuleta came back to perform. Looks like Archie is making quite a name for himself in the music biz and appears to still be a sweet guy.

OK, so now we are down to the fabulous five on "Idol." They are: Allison, Kris Allen, Adam Lambert, Danny Gokey and Matt Giraud. So, start exercising those fingers now because there is more texting and phoning to be done.

Allison. Photo courtesy of Fox

Allison. Photo courtesy of FOX

Finalists dazzle during disco night

 

 

Disco got done up right on Tuesday night.

The seven finalists dabbled in the disco era and some performed as if they were born to boogie on that "Idol" stage, while others may see America ditch them like a white polyester pant suit. Also, the stakes are even higher after Tuesday's show. The judges decided to save Matt Giraud last week, which means that two finalists will head home this week. 

So, put on your boogie shoes, dust off your mirror ball and let's recap the night away. 

Lil Rounds -- Perhaps Lil should have selected the song "Last Dance" because it appears that she won't be with "Idol" very much longer. Or so say the judges. She performed "I'm Every Woman" and I, for one, actually enjoyed it. It looked as if Lil was finally having fun on the stage and she hit some strong notes. However, the judges thought it lacked originality and believe she will be booted. I have to agree. I am a Lil fan but I think bad song choices have plagued her since she got to Hollywood.

Kris Allen -- Adam Lambert better watch his back because Kris is creeping up on him fast in the creativity department. Kris performed "She Works Hard for the Money" and blew the audience away with his Santana-like arrangement with the song. Kris is starting to seem like this season's Jason Castro --without the dreadlocks. I mean that as a compliment because I always looked forward to Jason's take on a song. I feel that way about Kris, and I love his vocals and verve.

Danny Gokey -- Danny did not really wow me with his take on "September." Sure his vocals were strong but the arrangement lacked originality. The judges took Lil to task because they felt her song was too much like the original but said nothing about Danny doing the same thing. Still, I do enjoy Danny's voice. I just feel like we keep seeing the same performance from him over and over again. It's big song, big notes, big finish. Wash, rinse and repeat. I'd like to see Danny change things up more often.

Allison Iraheta -- Speaking of changing things up with a song, that's exactly what Allison did with her rocked-out rendition of "Hot Stuff." It was cool and edgy, and I have never heard that type of arrangement for the song. While the judges weren't thrilled with the arrangement, they thought she did a brilliant job singing.

Adam Lambert -- I've got to give Adam props again for coming up with a creative take on a song. He chose "If I Can't Have You" and slowed it way down to a ballad. So, yeah, it was interesting but it wasn't a hit for me. I like Adam's sensitive soulful side, but I think he slowed the song down too much. It felt too choppy in segments when it should have been smoother. But, mark my words, Adam will be in the top two. The judges adore him, and it is exciting to see what he will come up with next.

Matt Giraud -- Mr. Saved from 'Idol' Oblivion did his best to show the judges that they made the right decision. He performed "Stayin' Alive" and, again, showed his Justin Timberlake-ish qualities with his strut and strong singing. I am not sure if it will be enough to keep him in the competition but it was better than Anoop's performance.

Anoop Desai -- Anoop chose "Dim All The Lights," which was appropriate because it made me want to fall asleep. He is a talented singer, but I found this performance to be so boring and the song was not memorable. Simon called it Anoop's worst performance. I wouldn't go that far but I do think it was a snoozer. 

OK, so here's who I think may be headed home: Lil, Anoop or Matt.  What about you other fans out there? Who wowed you on Tuesday, and name the finalists you think are destined to play their funky music for the last time?

Lil Rounds

Lil Rounds

 

Anoop Desai

Anoop Desai

Matt Giraud gets another go

Matt Giraud was saved by the belles.

Oh come on, you know it was those brunette belles at the judges table who were probably Matt's most vocal supporters. Ultimately, though, when the judges decided to use their special save option this season it had to be a unanimous vote.

So, Matt makes "Idol" history as the first contestant to get the judges' save. How wild was that on Wednesday? I did not think they would do it, especially after Simon's comments about how Matt probably doesn't have a chance at winning. But those wily judges went ahead and saved him anyway. Of course, Mr. Cowell did have to rain on the parade of joy a little when he said that next week two people will be going home. Plus, it will be disco week, which sometimes proves to be a tough theme for finalists.

And, truth be told, Matt from Michigan may just find himself leaving that "Idol" stage next week when two have to go. Lil Rounds may join him, just like she did Wednesday as one of the lowest vote-getters. Anoop Desai rounded out the bottom three in the results show.

Let's get back to Matt, though. Was he save-worthy in your opinion? Overall, I am a Matt fan. Sometimes his song choices leave me puzzled, but I do think the piano man has pizazz. Unfortunately, I found his performance during Tuesday's "songs from the movies" show to be uneven. He chose "Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman" and the beginning of the song was great but the last part was pitchy.

While I appreciate that the judges gave him another chance, I keep going back to how Simon said Matt doesn't really have a shot at winning. Simon is probably right. Still, with improvement, Matt could end up in the top five. Of course, that depends on how well he does with disco.

Lil is another person who needs to up her game next week because she could soon be saying adios. I think the disco theme could serve her well. That is, if she actually picks the right song for her vocals.

And speaking of disco, I am already pumped about that theme for next week. I am eager to see if the finalists will dazzle or disappoint me with their disco ditties.

OK, now I want to know your thoughts about Wednesday's show. Did you think Matt would be the one to earn the save or do you think the judges made a mistake? Also, do you think it's fair that the judges even have this option? So, please share your views on these "Idol" issues. An inquiring mind wants to know.

Matt Giraud. Photo source MTV

Matt Giraud. Photo by FOX

Tinseltown tunes not so terrific for some

Movie night on "Idol" was more lackluster than a blockbuster.

Granted, it wasn't exactly the equivalent of a box-office bomb, but there certainly were not a lot of award-winning performances. It is a shame, really, because I do like the "music from the movies" theme, but some of the seven finalists seemed to struggle with finding a hit.

Before we delve into that, though, there are a few things that struck me about the overall show. I wasn't certain what kind of a mentor Quentin Tarantino would make, and I laughed a little when Ryan called the director a "legend." Successful with some films, yes. But a legend? Not quite. Of course, I should have disclosed first that I am not a Tarantino film fan. But I do appreciate that he is an "Idol" fan and I liked the excitement he brought during his mentoring sessions. Overall, he was fun.

Also, I found it interesting that each singer only got to hear comments from two judges in an effort to save time. Hmm, so there's not enough time during a show to hear comments from four judges? Makes you wonder why a fourth judge was added in the first place, huh? And speaking of judges, Paula was off her rocker Tuesday night. She was in some kind of fortune-cookie comment mode. Take these two gems that she spouted off to Adam Lambert: "You dare to dance in the path of greatness" and "Fortune rewards the brave." What the what? I am thinking Paula is concentrating more on how much bling she will wear instead of coming up with a critique that makes sense.

OK, now to the main attraction, the performances.

Allison Iraheta -- She chose the song "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" from the movie "Armageddon." She sounded too breathless in the beginning of the song but I thought her performance picked up and sounded better as it continued. The judges enjoyed it, and Simon told her that she is the only hope the girls' have left in the competition. Still, I can't say that I really loved her performance. I like rock ballads but this one was kind of boring for me.  

Anoop Desai -- Anoop took one of the most overplayed songs ever (but still one of my favorites) "Everything I Do I Do It for You" and turned in a great performance. He did make a few minor changes with the pacing of the song that was featured in "Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves" and, ultimately, did a solid job with it.

Adam Lambert -- I'll say this for him, he always comes up with something creative. I may loathe some of his song choices but he does do them up differently each time. He took on "Born to Be Wild" from the movie "Easy Rider" and made it into a heavy metal/dance music hybrid. Overall, it did not get this music fan's motor running. I have to agree with Simon when he said the vocals were incredible but some parts were like watching "The Rocky Horror Picture Show."

Matt Giraud -- I thought Matt's opening of "Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman" was incredible but then the song hit a rough pitchy patch. The tune from "Don Juan DeMarco" is one I enjoy but I wish Matt would have kept that tender vibe he had at the beginning of the performance all the way through.

Danny Gokey -- Danny changed it up a little Tuesday night and took a distinctly simple and toned-down approach to "Endless Love" from the movie of the same name. It was beautiful but, like Simon said, a kind of boring and traditional version of the song.

Kris Allen -- For starters, I think the song "Falling Slowly" from the film "Once" is beautiful. I wouldn't use that same adjective, though, to describe his version of the song. Yes, it was nice and Kris hit some glory notes but he was also pitchy and it just didn't seem that the song truly suited his voice.

Lil Rounds -- OK, so I think Lil did much better in this show than she has previously. She chose "The Rose" from the movie of the same name, and I thought the beginning was spectacular. She should have continued that soft and sweet arrangement all the way through. I love gospel music but I don't think the gospel approach she used in the middle of the song really worked. It didn't sound all that seamless. That first part, though, was terrific.

OK, so which singer in the bunch will be packing his/her bags? My guess is that it will be Matt. I enjoy Matt but I am afraid his performance on Tuesday won't be enough to convince fans that he should stay.

Enough with my ramblings. What did you all think of the movie song themed show? Was it a big hit or a major miss?

Anoop Desai

Anoop Desai

Matt Giraud

Matt Giraud

Scott ended 'Idol' run as a class act

Perhaps Paula Abdul said it best in describing Scott MacIntyre, the latest finalist to say adios on "Idol."

"You are one classy gentleman. God bless you. We love you," she said as he left the stage for good on Wednesday.

The Arizona native, who is legally blind, did prove to be a nice guy throughout the competition and certainly has some singing skills and is a wonderful pianist. The problem is that he just wasn't in the same league as the other finalists, especially after Tuesday night's less than memorable performance of the ballad "The Search Is Over" by Survivor.

Ultimately, Scott wasn't always the most entertaining of the contestants, but he was one of the most endearing.

Scott was joined in the bottom three by Anoop Desai and Lil Rounds. Anoop's appearance surprised me because I thought he did a fantastic job on "True Colors" by Cyndi Lauper. As for Lil, though, she seems to be struggling. She tackled Tina Turner's "What's Love Got To Do With It" and brought nothing new or magical to the song. I'm hoping that Lil's bottom-three slot might be enough to encourage her to start picking better songs. Lil, please start showing that big talent.

OK, that's enough from me. What did you other fans think about Scott's departure? Did America make the right choice? Also, I know it's still early, but who do you think will make it to the final two? And will the judges ever use this special "save" that they keep talking about. All these questions and so little time. So, give me a shout-out and share what you are seeing through your "Idol" eyes.

Birth-year theme brings baby pics, song blasts from the past

 

Tuesday's birth-year theme certainly delivered.

Oh sure, it was fun to see photos of the eight finalists and the judges when they were wee ones but, more than that, "Idol" fans got the gift of some great performances.

Not all of the eight were worth celebrating, mind you. There are two finalists who should probably be worried going into the results show because their b-day year songs were a bust.

So, let's blow out the candles and get this "Idol" party started.

Danny Gokey -- Gokey the great got down to business with a version of "Stand By Me" that was covered by country singer Mickey Gilley. Interestingly enough, there was not a country-esque quality to the song. Instead, it was an arrangement packed with funk. I actually liked that Danny tried something different with the classic song. It was not my all-time favorite Danny ditty but it certainly was fun to hear.

Kris Allen -- I am crazy for Kris, but Tuesday was not my favorite performance from him. He chose "All She Wants To Do Is Dance" by Don Henley. The arrangement was a bit weird. It was a jazz/funk combo that did not fit with the song. Simon called the performance "boring" and "forgettable" and, as much as it pains me to say, I have to agree. Come on Kris, try harder next week.

Lil Rounds -- What is up with Lil? I really thought the woman was going to do wonderful things on the show. There is no question she has a powerful voice, but her song choices do nothing to flatter her talents. She took on Tina Turner's "What's Love Got To Do With It," which was just wrong, wrong, wrong. That is a signature Tina song, and Lil just came across as an OK impersonator. Lil seems to have become a shell of what she once was earlier in the season when she was sassing it up Mary J. Blige style. I miss that Lil, really I do. I think there is a good chance that Lil will end up in the bottom three on Wednesday. Maybe that would be a good thing because it could light a fire in her to really find her signature songs.

Anoop Desai -- Anoop definitely improved from last week's Usher debacle. He chose one of my favorite tunes, "True Colors" by Cyndi Lauper. It had an R&B ring to it, which I liked, and some great vocals. 

Scott MacIntyre -- If lite FM ever needed a poster boy, they have found one in Scott. He took on the power ballad "The Search Is Over" that I am sure is being played on some lite FM radio station as I type this. I have never been a fan of the Survivor song and Scott's version of the tune didn't do anything to change that. I appreciated that he tried to change things up by trading the piano for a guitar but, even then, it was just bland overall. I think Scott should be the next finalist to leave. He is a great guy but doesn't stand out enough from the rest of the crew.

Allison Iraheta -- One of the things I enjoy about Allison is how she has such a distinctive voice. I like the raspy quality to it, which really comes out when she rocks the stage. Tuesday night, though, she showed a tender side with "I Can't Make You Love Me" by Bonnie Raitt. It was a nice ballad and gave her a chance to show off some skills with slow songs. I prefer the rocker chick but this was fine for now.

Matt Giraud -- Matt turned to a Stevie Wonder tune to try to wow audiences again. For the most part, I think he did with his take on "Part Time Lover." It was jazzy and fun and should be enough to keep him out of the bottom three again. Hopefully.

Adam Lambert -- I am going to make this prediction now: Adam will be one of the top two on the show. I feel it, I sense it, I might even go to Vegas and place a bet on it. OK, not so much with the last part only because I am tight with my money and a lousy gambler. But, if I were a betting woman, I would definitely put Adam in until the bitter end. Granted, I am still not setting up residence in the Adam camp, but I do think he was the best performer in Tuesday's show. Adam's falsetto performances are fascinating, like he proved during Motown week and again this week with "Mad World" from Tears For Fears. It was a very moving song and even Simon gave it a standing ovation. For me, Adam is at his best when he takes on a slow song instead of the '80s hair band screeching he does in other songs.

OK, time to wrap up this "Idol" entry. What did you all think about Tuesday's show? Were the birth-year songs a reason to celebrate or bad trips down memory lane?

Adam Lambert

Adam Lambert

Megan makes her exit

Megan and her awkward dance moves have gone away.

Actually, that doesn't mean awkward dance moves are no more for this season. Danny Gokey may just bust out more silly moves in future shows.

I am the first to admit that I am no dancing queen. That's why I prefer to dance in groups and not alone on a stage. I guess Megan is braver than I am.

But enough about the dancing, Megan's departure was not a big surprise. I was baffled about why she seemed to be all kinds of excited about being in the bottom three. What was that goofy frightened face all about, huh? But it felt like when Simon told her that there was no shot that the judges would save her, the reality of leaving finally sunk in and the tears started to flow.

So, goodbye Megan. You did make for an interesting contestant on "Idol" with your different vibe.

Megan was joined in the bottom three by Anoop Desai and Allison Iraheta. Anoop's appearance there did not shock me. He got a lackluster response from the judges in Tuesday's show. But now I am starting to get worried about little Allison. True, I wasn't wowed by her performance Tuesday but, overall, I am a big fan. I hope she gets her groove back next week.

As for the rest of the results show, I was mighty impressed by last season's champ David Cook. I was not all about David last season but I am slowly becoming more of a fan. His new single "Come Back to Me" sounds like it will be another hit for him.

And what to say about Lady Gaga? I guess she is weirdly entertaining. I am not gaga about her but did find it neat that she can play the piano.

One thing I am gaga about is next week's theme, which allows the finalists to pick songs from the year they were born. I can't wait to see and hear what they present.

Megan Joy

Megan Joy

Kris Allen shows he is an all-star

Kris Allen is more than all right. The guy is outta sight.

The Arkansas cutie took a classic song -- "Ain't No Sunshine" -- and made it creative and contemporary.  He started off softly and then rocked it up. It was the definite hit on an otherwise ho-hum night of performances. Oh sure, the premise of Tuesday's show sounded promising. The nine finalists got to choose songs from the most popular downloads on iTunes. Ultimately, though, only a few really stepped up. And, sadly, some of my favorites appear to be struggling.

So, let's get down to "Idol" business and run through the performances.

Anoop Desai -- Anoop went back to his R&B groove and sang "Caught Up" by Usher. It didn't score points for originality but, overall, I thought it was OK. However, Randy thought Anoop picked the wrong song, and Simon called it a mess. It was not Anoop's best moment, but I don't know that it will be enough to send him off the show. He may land in the bottom three in the results, though.

Megan Joy -- Speaking of someone who should be in the bottom three -- actually, I will take that further -- speaking of someone who should be off the show, that would be one Megan Joy. Seriously. I have been willing to give the hippie chick a chance, but not after tonight. It seems as if she has tried all sorts of musical genres and has come up short with that baffling voice of hers. I am struggling to think of a song of hers I have enjoyed. It sure wasn't tonight's Bob Marley/Lauryn Hill song "Turn Your Lights Down Low." The judges didn't like the song choice, and Kara told Megan she may be in trouble on the show. I agree. Here's the thing; Megan is beautiful and appears to glow under those showbiz lights of the "Idol" stage. But the problem is that her voice doesn't shine on the show.

Danny Gokey -- I was amused when Danny said he wanted to tone down his performance this week and chose "What Hurts The Most" by Rascal Flatts. Did it seem that toned down to you? Because it sure didn't for me. I guess by "toned down" Danny meant that the song was soft enough in places where you could hear the violin. Anyhow, it still sounded as loud as Danny's usual performances, although it would have been nicer to see a softer side from him. Don't get me wrong, I liked the performance overall but just once I would like to see Danny bring it down a notch and pull out a soft soulful sound.

Allison Iraheta -- Hey Allison, Cyndi Lauper called. She wants her outfit back. Sorry, I couldn't help myself. It seemed like our rocker teen was channeling some 1980s Cyndi with that getup. I guess it was a distraction from her so-so performance of "Don't Speak" by No Doubt. The song seemed too low for Allison's voice, and I was not as impressed this week with her as I have been previously.

Scott MacIntyre -- At first, when Scott said he chose "Just The Way You Are" by Billy Joel, I was thinking the song would sound too dated. But, Scott surprised me. It was pleasant and better than his past performances. Also, I love the hair cut and/or use of product. Whatever it is, it works for him.

Matt Giraud -- It appears that last week's almost elimination for Matt has scared him silly on the show. He seems nervous and confused about what to do next. That is understandable, but I wish he would stick to the pop side of the musical fence he is straddling. I don't see him as a full-fledged rocker and I felt like he was trying to give "You Found Me" by The Fray more of a rock edge than the song needed. It just didn't suit him. I do hope America gives him another shot because I think he's got the goods.

Lil Rounds -- Lil is another finalist who seems to be nervous and confused about song choices. The judges haven't been too impressed with her as of late, so Lil pulled out all the diva stops on Tuesday with "I Surrender" by Celine Dion. For the life of me, I can't recall this Celine song, and I like Celine's work. It wasn't a great song, but Lil did kick it up a notch and the song got better as it went along. Like Simon said, it was too old-fashioned for her and managed to suck out her personality. On a positive note, Lil looked amazing in that gown.

Adam Lambert -- Adam wowed me last week during the Motown songs. This week, it was so-so. He chose "Play That Funky Music" by Wild Cherry. It was an unusual song choice, but I do think he made it contemporary and clever. I just don't think I would buy any of Adam's music if he does win "Idol." Check that, I would download his single of "The Tracks of My Tears." But that's it for now.

Kris Allen -- Talk about saving the best for last. Kris was stunning during his take on the Bill Withers tune. He showed us that he can take an oldie but a goody and make it a smash for today's audiences. Paula told him that if he makes an album, "Ain't No Sunshine" could be the first cut. I would so buy that album.

OK "Idol" fans, what did you think about the iTunes-themed show? Impressed? Interested in buying some of the finalists' tunes? Or would you diss that download?

Kris steals the show.

Kris steals the show.

Search

You are currently browsing the That TV Blog: Roanoke Times staff riff on their favorite television shows - Roanoke.com weblog archives for April, 2009.

About this blog

That TV Blog is the Roanoke Times' blog for all things TV. A handful of folks from our staff riff on their favorite and not-so-favorite shows here. | Read more about the contributors and this blog.

RSS feed

Comments

    • Marie Batten: Nona! late posting but my thoughts exactly….Adam is larger than IDOL. In retrospect, Im glad Kris...
    • Tony O: I realy liked Adam better. I loved the Bikini Girl and Kara’s Show….
    • Nona Nelson: It was better this year not to win if the winner is stuck recording that musical methane cloud “No...
    • Marilyn: Well, the new American Idol said it himself, when Ryan turned the mic to him. I hope you caught it, he said...
    • Nona Nelson: The song that Kara co-wrote was dreadful. And the winner will have to release that pile of fail as a...