.....Advertisement.....
.....Advertisement.....
The Wild Life, with Mark Taylor

An example of the mass on the Hartman buck

Here's a shot of the right G2 area on Chuck Hartman's buck. Pretty awesome, huh? (Click here to read today's story in The Roanoke Times, or better yet, go buy a paper!)

Because both of these points share a common base, one of these would be considered the G2 and the other would be an abnormal "sticker."  This trait renders the rack a non-typical in the eyes of Boone and Crockett.

I always hate to get too hung up on scores, but I understand a lot of people care about that. This trait really kills the score. Had these been separate points this rack would have been a typical 10 with two stickers.

I'm far from expert on scoring, but I think that means the rack's net typical score would be the gross minus penalities, the largests of which would be for the 7-inch drop tine. There would also be penalties for lack of symmetry, which would total up to a few points. (If I'm off base here, baseball pun not intended, someone feel free to chime in.)

So, if the gross non-typical score was around 184, as one expert who has measured the rack estimates, that would put the potential net typical score in the low- to mid-170s -- big enough to make the all-time Boone and Crockett book. And, just to give you an idea how rare that is, Virginia has just over a dozen typicals in the all-time book. (The record was 189 2/8, killed in Buchanan County in 1999.)

Of course while it's fun to speculate, it doesn't really matter. The rack is what it is, which is just a monstrous whitetail for Virginia or anywhere else.

2 Comments »

  1. Actually, the abnormal points aren't added to the gross on a typical score. Yet they are counted as deductions. Kind of a double whammy, but who cares - It's still a monster buck.

    Comment by FH — January 30, 2009 @ 2:16 pm

  2. the buck stops here

    Comment by James Salenger — January 31, 2009 @ 4:50 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Search

About this blog

Mark Taylor.

While growing up in rural Southern Oregon, Mark Taylor developed a passion for the outdoors while he and his younger brother tagged along with their father on fishing, hunting and camping adventures.

Graduating from Northwestern University in 1988, Taylor spent four years as an officer in the U.S. Navy based in Norfolk before moving into journalism.

After five years writing about the military for a Norfolk-based publishing company, he became the outdoors editor at The Roanoke Times in 1998. He lives in Roanoke with his wife and twin daughters.

RSS feed

Comments

  • Joey: way to go, awesome looking buck
  • B Casella: Congratulations, nice buck James!
  • John Branson: Kim, Piebald refers to the random white and brown patches of fur on the deer. It’s caused by a...
  • Brammer: Way to go Basham, good luck for the rest of the season.
  • J: Awesome Buck, even if it wasnt half white!